Week 2 A1: We participate therefore we are?

Reflections on the webcast by John Seely Brown  http://stadium.open.ac.uk/stadia/preview.php?whichevent=1063&s=31

Your work so far on H800 includes some individual reading, listening and perhaps viewing. Does Brown’s argument imply that this is less valuable than your group work? It is illogical for John Seely Brown to claim that study groups are the “best indicator for success” when he is asking us to listen to one person – himself! – in lecture mode.’


Well listened to the first 20 minutes for the talk – Personally I could listen to him all day – for me he has such a lovely way of speaking – although I admit that some of it went over my head though but some of it really struck a chord.

At first glance it might seem a bit contradictory ( perhaps illogical ) as the environment of the talk lends itself to a traditional lecture format and doesn’t embrace some of the techniques that would truly allow the audience to be part of the experience and therefore engage in collaborative learning  ( I say this of only the parts that I have viewed so far of course )

I agree that the purpose of Brown’s presentation was to endorse the value of study groups and for me the key thing here is that he focuses on the value of social construction of ‘understanding’ rather than the knowledge aspect. I don’t think he particularly mean that individual learning was less valuable , just that collaborative could offer additional value…?


 What are the implications of his argument for your own use of technology – in your own learning and teaching?As usual, please interpret ‘teaching’ very broadly to include a wide range of roles. If you are not working in technology-enhanced learning, consider the role of technology in your informal support of others – friends, family members, colleagues

For me I find it incredibly helpful to reinforce my own understanding of a concept within a group although I would certainly agree with some of the points that have been made on the discussion forum that discussions can be stressful ! I think the key to collaborative learning is creating a safe and respectful environment where people feel supported , valued and reassured that no question is a stupid one !

What are your reactions to Brown’s style of presentation? What are its strengths and weaknesses compared with other presentations you have seen?

I liked listening to him and it did not seem like ‘death by Powerpoint’  but again because of the potential contraction between the nature of the talk and the chosen talk environment, what would have been interesting to see is what happened after the lecture ?  I quickly whizzed to the end but it does stop at the end of the talk which is of course not unusual but I did wonder did people talk about it afterwards ?  Would that interaction led to a deeper level of understanding  of the issues raised in the talk and as that would have taken place in a social context would that have then backed up Seely Brown’s argument that ‘Understanding not knowledge is socially constructed ?’



About Debbaff

Senior Academic Developer at Swansea University Open Educational Resources and Practice Enthusiast Open Digital Badges Lover ... PhD Student in E- Research and Technology Enhanced Learning .. loves Cats and anything Pink ...

Posted on February 14, 2015, in MA ODE, Useful and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. Comments Off on Week 2 A1: We participate therefore we are?.

Comments are closed.


Open Digital Badges

The MoonshotEdu Show

fun, forecasts, foibles, & frontiers in education innovation

Maren Deepwell

CEO & Open Practitioner, sharing my approach to leadership in Learning Technology


Learning across the margins

SueG's Weblog

Dr Sue Greener is interested in online learning, developing people and explaining things clearly. Her blog includes references to research and its practical application in Higher Education as a subset of the wider field of work.

Messy Thinking

life as a connected leader.

digital academic

digital shifts - learning and teaching in higher education


A blog to take my learning forward.


Middlebury College

Debbie Baff

Portfolio of Work


'Inspiring Teaching, Enhancing Assessment and Engaging Students'

Fiona Harvey.

Be useful.


My own reflections on technology enhanced learning @katessoper

Technology Enhanced Learning Blog

Observations and ideas from University of Derby's Technology Enhanced Learning Team and other TEL practitioners

How to Do Great Research

Grad school survival advice from Nick Feamster and Alex Gray


A place for my thoughts on my PHD Journey


Better teaching through technology


Improve your digital skills one minute at a time

Sara Hawkins

Attorney at Law


The hopeless dream of being—not seeming, but being.

Etale - Education, Innovation, Experimentation

curiosity, love of learning, analysis, synthesis, experimentation, creation, wisdom, the spirit of entrepreneurship, the pursuit of democratization

High Heels and Healthy Meals

Dating, dieting and all that's inbetween

OER World Map

Blog for the OER World Map project funded by The Hewlett Foundation

Scottx5's Blog

Thoughts on Community

Danny considers...

A place for reflection, commentary, sharing of useful resources and general ramblings

The Thesis Whisperer

Just like the horse whisperer - but with more pages

The Research Whisperer

Just like the Thesis Whisperer - but with more money


Just another WordPress.com site

@Ignatia Webs

A blog about my open learning experiences ... and a few other bits of ordinary life

Sue Beckingham: US Study Tour 2011

...exploring the potential of using social media in higher ed to enhance student engagement

Isobel Gowers

Reflections on Learning and Teaching

Espace Sisyphe

épuisant le champ du possible

Open World

Lorna M Campbell

Flexible, Open and Social Learning

A cross-boundary professional development course

Amber at Warwick: academic technology

technology thinking for teaching and research

Alaska Ed Tech

A teacher's journey through the 21st Century


The weekly Learning and Teaching in HE chat created by the community for the community - Wednesday 8-9pm


John Millner's MAODE blog

The Ed Techie

on open education, digital scholarship & over-stretched metaphors

Online Learning Insights

A place for learning about online education

Ministering to Education

Leighton Andrews AM

Opening up learning

by Paul Bacsich


Rhizomes and knitting

Social Media for Learning

Helping you get started using social media for learning, teaching and research


Bring Your Own Devices for Learning: an open learning event for students & teachers (facilitated, stand-alone)

%d bloggers like this: